Reviving the Padres’ Offense: Key Adjustments to Turn Things Around
The San Diego Padres have kicked off the 2025 season in remarkable fashion, currently holding the second-best record in MLB. Fernando Tatis Jr. is making a strong case for MVP, the bullpen has been dominant, and the starting rotation has held up well despite missing ace Yu Darvish. On the surface, it’s shaping up to be one of the most promising starts in franchise history.
However, there’s one glaring issue that has emerged during their recent 2-4 road trip—offense. The Padres have been struggling to score, averaging a mere 2.5 runs per game. While Tatis, Manny Machado, and Gavin Sheets are carrying the load at the top of the order, the rest of the lineup has faltered, raising concerns about whether the Padres can sustain their hot start. But before fans start hitting the panic button, there are several factors that could help unlock this offense and get it back on track.
Injuries Are Taking a Toll
The most obvious culprit behind the Padres’ offensive woes is a string of key injuries. Jackson Merrill, Luis Arraez, and Jake Cronenworth are all currently sidelined, and all three are expected to return within a month. These aren’t just depth pieces—Merrill is a future star, Arraez is a three-time batting champion, and Cronenworth is a two-time All-Star. When you lose a third of your starting lineup, it’s bound to impact offensive production. Once these players return, the Padres’ lineup will regain its depth, and the questions about their offensive depth will likely fade.
It’s Time to Move On From Struggling Veterans
Another factor contributing to the Padres’ offensive struggles is the underperformance of certain veterans. Yuli Gurriel, now 40 years old, has been abysmal with a 9 OPS+, and hasn’t posted a strong offensive season since 2021. Similarly, Jason Heyward, currently on the injured list, has posted a .190 average and a .540 OPS. While both provide leadership in the clubhouse, their offensive contributions have been minimal, and the Padres may be better off seeking fresh talent in their place.
Young Talent Could Be the Spark
The Padres have two young players who are more than capable of stepping up—Tirso Ornelas and Luis Campusano. Ornelas, recently called up to platoon in left field, hasn’t had a hit yet in limited at-bats, but he’s coming off an impressive AAA season and a strong Spring Training. Campusano is absolutely crushing it in AAA, boasting a 1.157 OPS, and has shown promise in his previous major league stints. Both could inject much-needed life into the lineup and provide a spark in left field and DH.
Bottom Line: Patience is Key
At the end of the day, the Padres’ offensive struggles are largely tied to injuries and underperforming veterans. Once Merrill, Arraez, and Cronenworth return, the offense will have a much deeper, more potent look. In the meantime, giving the young guys a shot in the lineup could provide the boost the Padres need. If that doesn’t pan out, free agents like David Peralta or J.D. Martinez are still available to plug the gaps.