The Philadelphia Phillies’ early 2025 season has taken a concerning turn, echoing the same problems that ended their 2024 playoff run. Following a disappointing sweep by the New York Mets, the team’s record sits at a shaky 13-12—and the warning signs are hard to ignore. Here are seven glaring issues threatening to derail the Phillies’ campaign.
1. Bullpen Breakdown
Philadelphia’s bullpen has been one of the worst in baseball. They rank 29th in ERA (5.56), 25th in WHIP (1.53), and last in opponent batting average (.283). They’ve also blown a league-high seven saves. Free-agent signee Jordan Romano has struggled mightily with a 13.50 ERA, while fellow relievers Orion Kerkering, Joe Ross, Carlos Hernandez, and Jose Ruiz have all underperformed.
2. Bases-Loaded Blues
The offense has been frustratingly ineffective with runners in scoring position, especially with the bases loaded. The team has gone just 4-for-26 (.154) in those scenarios, ranking 25th in MLB. Their overall .251 average with runners in scoring position is mediocre, reflecting a larger issue with clutch hitting.
3. Realmuto’s Decline
Veteran catcher J.T. Realmuto is posting disappointing numbers: a .233 average, .309 OBP, and only one home run. With an OPS+ of 82 and no clear successor behind the plate, his future with the team is uncertain as he approaches free agency.
4. Turner’s Mega-Deal Looking Risky
Trea Turner, signed to an 11-year, $300 million deal, is underperforming again. He has just one home run, a .684 OPS, and a strikeout rate over 30%. While once seen as the final piece of a championship puzzle, his recent struggles are raising serious concerns.
5. Bohm’s Power Drought
Alec Bohm has shown flashes of form but remains ineffective overall, with no home runs, a .508 OPS, and a league-leading five double plays. His post-All-Star break slump from last season seems to have continued into 2025.
6. Marsh’s Vanishing Act
Before landing on the IL, Brandon Marsh was hitting just .095 in April. Despite being trusted as the everyday center fielder, his offensive collapse has left a hole in the lineup.
7. Nola’s Regression
Once a reliable ace, Aaron Nola is no longer the stabilizing force the Phillies need. His diminished performance adds pressure to an already struggling rotation.
If these issues persist, Philadelphia’s postseason hopes could be in serious jeopardy.